I’ve always found it curious that TechCrunch publishes articles around every Y Combinator Demo Day with titles like “16 of the most interesting startups from YC W26 Demo Day”. Apparently thousands of investors read these articles, but are journalists really in a position to tell them which YC startups will become tomorrow’s unicorns?
Since Rebel Fund tracks millions of datapoints across every YC startup, founder, and outcome in history, in large part to train our proprietary Rebel Theorem 5.0 ML/AI algorithm, we’re in a great position to answer questions like this. So, I asked my data science team to analyze all 2,498 YC startups from the W21 to F24 batches vs the 194 startups that TechCrunch highlighted across its Demo Day articles to see whether these companies were more likely to raise a Series A or later (or fail) vs their YC peers. The short answer is that investors should ignore these TechCrunch articles.
The TechCrunch-highlighted startups performed the same as their YC batch mates. 18.0% reached Series A or later against a 17.6% cohort average, and 14.4% shut down against a 16.8% cohort average. Both gaps sit well inside what any random list of the same size would produce.
They named winners in the same proportion that they named companies. TechCrunch highlighted 7.8% of the companies across those batches and 8.0% of those that reached Series A — exactly what you’d expect by pure chance.
Most YC-focused venture funds don’t do any better. This was our most surprising finding and the one that will get me the most evil looks at Demo Day 😳
Now here are the receipts:
This chart compares the Series A+ graduation rate and shutdown rate of TechCrunch’s picks vs their YC cohort. You’ll see TechCrunch’s companies perform only marginally better.

To see how much of TechCrunch’s small ‘outperformance’ is due to chance, we ran 20,000 Monte Carlo simulations to see where their predictions fall on the distribution curve, and they’re well within what’s considered random noise.

In some batches the TechCrunch picks did better than average and in some they did worse — further evidence that chance is mostly at play here.

When we looked at the mean return multiple of the TechCrunch-highlighted companies vs their peers, the numbers are nearly identical, again pointing more towards noise over signal.

While we were at it, we compared the early success (Series A+ graduation) rate to failure (shutdown) rate of the TechCrunch ‘portfolio’ vs the 7 most active venture funds investing into Y Combinator startups. In fairness to our journalist friends, most of these funds don’t perform any better.
This chart compares the portfolio early success-to-failure ratio of the YC-focused venture funds (including Rebel) vs TechCrunch. To protect the innocent, we redacted every fund name but our own.

As you’ll see, 2 of the venture funds slightly underperformed TechCrunch, 2 slightly overperformed, and 3 did much better. Many of these funds have raised hundreds of millions of dollars. Rebel had the highest ratio.
To separate signal and noise, we analyzed which venture funds’ performance was beyond what we’d expect due to chance at their portfolio size, and the same 3 funds came out on top. This means the other 4 funds, like TechCrunch, did about the same as throwing darts at a YC dartboard.

Before I get tar and feathered for publishing this, a few disclaimers:
We did this analysis with publicly available data on YC startups and outcomes so anyone with the desire and resources can reproduce it.
We only looked at early startup success vs failure metrics and not long-term performance (though the former is likely predictive of the latter).
TechCrunch is not a venture fund and they do great work for the YC ecosystem as journalists by highlighting interesting startups.
Investor performance at YC Demo Day averages is very good so even the ‘worst’ funds in our analysis are probably making their LPs happy. Garry Tan said that investors who backed YC companies from the 2018–2020 batches saw a median ~5x return, with the bottom quartile at ~3x.
So, the bottom line is TechCrunch’s picks don’t perform any better than chance, most YC-focused venture funds don’t pick much better, and only a few funds produce true alpha. Can anyone recommend a good bodyguard?

